The Great British Bake Off Musical

As this was my first experience of The Great British Bake Off Musical, it was refreshing to see something so different from the usual musical theatre repertoire. Crigglestone Community Theatre Company took on the challenge of staging the West Yorkshire premiere with confidence and imagination, guided by the now well-established creative partnership of Dean Patrick (Director), Wil Jones (Musical Director) and Katie Binns (Choreographer), whose experience working together on several productions was evident throughout.

The musical opened in unexpectedly prehistoric fashion with cave people discovering the joys of baking, a quirky beginning that initially puzzled the audience before cleverly linking to the show’s central idea that baking has always brought people together.

Once inside the familiar white tent, presenters Jim (Harriet Winstanley) and Kim (Fiona Welburn) guided us through the competition with warmth, humour and polished television charm. The real emotional core of the production, however, emerged through the developing relationship between Ben (Dan Wilkinson) and Gemma (Hannah Gaughn).

Ben entered the competition as a widowed father, encouraged by his daughter Lily (Emily Carritt) to rediscover joy and purpose through baking. Dan Wilkinson consistently gave 100% to the role, creating a warm, sincere character who the audience genuinely rooted for and wanted to see reach a happy ending. His performance carried real emotional honesty, although at times his accent became slightly unclear, which occasionally made key lines difficult to follow.

Through shared challenges, light-hearted kitchen chaos and increasingly tender moments, Gemma’s friendship with Ben gradually developed into a touching romance. This was beautifully underscored by the musical’s more reflective numbers and heartfelt duets, which gave their storyline genuine emotional weight and provided a strong anchor amid the humour and competition.

Hannah Gaughn delivered a performance with many strengths, particularly in her natural stage presence, warmth and ability to create an engaging and believable character within ensemble scenes. She brought a likeable openness to Gemma that made her journey easy to invest in. A constructive area for development would be allowing more time within the performance to fully shape Gemma’s character arc, ensuring the emotional progression feels even more clearly defined so that the audience can see a stronger and more detailed journey from beginning to end.

Around them, the other bakers each added their own flavour to the tent. Babs (Claire Adams) offered warmth and traditional family values, Izzy (Genevieve Shaw) showed determination to prove herself as a natural winner, but soon realised she was out of her depth and had to resort to dirty tactics, whilst Hassan (Macauley Welburn) baked from the heart using cherished family traditions and created a character full of loveable swagger, Russell (Scott Hill) quietly grew in confidence as the weeks progressed, and Francesca (Kaly Nicholson) brought competitive ambition and drive. Dezza (Joshua Hoyle) arrived full of youthful confidence and infectious enthusiasm and even after his  elimination, his refusal to step away from the Bake Off family, added an extra layer of comedy to the ensemble and reinforced the show’s message that belonging mattered more than winning.

The judges, Phil Hollinghurst (Nick Harvey-Wade) and Pam Lee (Nicola Duval), provided many of the production’s comic highlights through their contrasting personalities and sharply delivered critiques. Harvey-Wade convincingly maintained Phil’s distinctive Liverpudlian accent throughout, capturing warmth and understated humour, while Duval leaned fully into Pam’s persona as a brand in herself—status-driven, image-conscious and fiercely protective of her reputation. This exaggerated focus on prestige and perfection brought much of the comedy, forming a strong contrast with Phil’s more grounded approach.

Supporting the principals throughout was an energetic television crew who ensured seamless scene transitions and kept the pace of the competition flowing. The set, hired from the aptly named Salt & Pepper Productions, worked effectively in recreating the bustling environment of the Bake Off tent.

Katie Binns’ choreography made excellent use of the stage during the ensemble numbers, Wil Jones drew confident and well-balanced performances from cast and chorus alike, and Dean Patrick’s direction successfully blended humour, competition and emotional storytelling into a cohesive whole.

By the finale, The Great British Bake Off Musical had proven to be far more than a light-hearted parody. It had become a warm, character-driven story of resilience, friendship, love and second chances, with Ben and Gemma’s relationship standing at its emotional heart and giving the production real depth and heart. Crigglestone Community Theatre Company deserved great credit for delivering a confident and engaging West Yorkshire premiere with clear affection for both the material and its audience.

© NODA CIO. All rights reserved.